Friday, February 4, 2011

Blog 3: The Dumbest Generation




Reading the article about Mark Bauerlein's "The Dumbest Generation" was really eye-opening to me. I always had a problem with technology, but it hasn't ever stopped me from using it as much as the next person. However, his stereotype of us as the dumbest generation was a little shocking to me. I had never thought of it that way. I guess I always saw the creation and use of continually advancing technology as a sign of intelligence from our generation. I always knew the importance of the historical aspects of our American culture, but I never realized how ignorant even I was of this information. There was a line in the article that said, "The old have been wringing their hands about the young's cultural wastelands and ignorance of history at least since admirers of Sophocles and Aeschylus bemoaned the popularity of Aristophanes ('The Frogs,' for Zeussakes?!) as leading to the end of (Greek) civilization as they knew it." WHAT??! I couldn't tell you who a single one of those people were, or what that sentence even meant. If we're the dumbest generation, I have to say I'm one of the dumb. I really liked the clip from Jay Leno that we watched in class, and I found another "Jaywalking" video that went right along with the "quiz" we took in class.

While discussing this week's literature and media in class, I felt that everyone was getting really defensive about our generation. And why wouldn't they? That's US this guy is talking about! I'd say calling us "the dumbest generation" is a pretty big insult, considering the generations and generations of people before us. But he does have some points. We're incompetent about a lot of things and, as we found out during class on Thursday, unwilling to learn about things that seem to hold no relevance to our lives. I've always loved reading and going to school because I like learning new things, so I can definitely see both sides of the argument. 

                                                        
Like everyone else, I depend on technology for almost everything, from getting directions (because I can barely read a map) to finding out all about the life of Will Smith. However, I hate how much I depend on it. It bothers me that I can't NOT get on Facebook, or that whenever I feel bored for a minute I pick up my computer. But that's the way it is. It's become so convenient in many ways - for communication, to look up information, to shop, etc. We would be foolish to not use the Internet; after all, that's what it was made for. But it's taken away our drive. The article in Newsweek quoted Bauerlein as saying that "kids these days are just as smart and motivated as ever," but I'm not convinced that that's entirely true. I definitely think that we're just as smart, and I think that a lot of intelligent young people are going to do amazing things in the future. I don't believe, however, that we're equally as motivated as our parents generation was, at least not in the same sense. To many of us, going to school was just... expected. We had a choice, but we never REALLY had a choice. For my parents and grandparents, going to school was basically a privilege. They valued hard work and felt really proud if they did well on something because they knew how hard they had tried and worked for it. Not that none of us do that today, but most of us just expect information to fall into our laps. Teachers should only teach us what's going to be on the test, and give us study guides, and definitely not have cumulative finals. Basically, we think that college should be easy. But the doctors of today had to work pretty hard to make it through med school; would you want to be operated on by someone who didn't really learn anything except how to pass a test?

I tutor a 9th grader and I noticed that he has a very limited vocabulary. I thought about how I had always been told to read with a dictionary beside me so that I could look up words I didn't know. But that isn't very practical today; why would you spend money on a dictionary when you can take 2 seconds and look up a word on Google? In this aspect, I definitely understand our pull towards technology. It's hard to accept Mark Bauerlein's accusation that we're "dumb" because in a way, we know so much more than our parents do. At least about technology! Though there are many gaps in our knowledge about other things. Like we discussed in class, many think that the information we know is more important to our generation than knowing the composer of "Carmina Burana." Whether we like it or not, technology is moving forward. I think that if we don't learn how to use it, we'll be left behind, much like our grandparents and technologically illiterate parents. We may not like it, but it is what it is. 


With all of that being said, I think that we should still have a craving to learn about the arts and history of our past. I think it's important to understand the things of the past to know where the things of the present have come from. Some people, especially liberal arts majors, still see the value in learning this knowledge. But I think more people are focused on what they specifically want to do and find other knowledge unnecessary. I think that people that major in music should learn about the sciences, and I think science majors should also have to learn about some famous composers. Having a wide range of knowledge will be beneficial to us because it allows us to know and understand more about the world that we live in.


                                                   


But like the article said, "Writing off any generation before it's thirty is what's dumb." The hope in our generation should not be lost yet! We have plenty of time to prove Mark Bauerlein wrong. Though I don't think our generation will ever be focused on classical music or the art of Picasso, I think that there is a big chance that many medical and technological advancements will be made to better our society and others. 

4 comments:

  1. I really liked how you incorporated the 9th grader you tutor into this blog. I liked seeing a real life example of how unrealistic it is to do what other generations would consider normal, like reading with a dictionary. Even though Bauerlein thinks that we are the dumbest generation, we do know a lot even if it is about technology. I like the quote “whether we like it or not, technology is moving forward. I think that if we don't learn how to use it, we'll be left behind, much like our grandparents and technologically illiterate parents. We may not like it, but it is what it is”. This statement is so true and to the point. Even though we don’t know what Bauerlein considers to be important, we know a lot about what we need to know in today’s society.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree when you say that we should have a wide range of knowledge. Because I am an education major, I am expected to take classes from all areas. Although I am not really a fan, I understand why I do have to take these classes. All the sciences I am taking do seem kind of pointless to me because I have a concentration in math and language arts. But, these classes are giving me a variety of knowledge so that in case a students asks me for help in a different area, I will be aware. In a way, all the different subjects connect to each other which does make everything relevant. Without math, we couldn't use science, and there is history behind science, and a lot of books required to read have to deal with history. Without having this background knowledge, I know I wouldn't be able to help my students succeed.

    ReplyDelete
  3. That is so true technology is always advancing. Since we are such a technological generation then, we will always be up on the latest dish. I think it is crazy to think that we are the "Dumbest Generation." How can one of the most technologically savvy generations ever be considered stupid. I mean yes, there are some aspects we are pretty dumb but, again how can we be so stupid if we can figure out how to use the newest and hottest technology equipment. In a short time period.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh my dear lord, I had a huge paragraph then my computer lost connection.....these are the times that I hate technology, like seriously, THANKS!

    Well, anmyways, I'll just sum up exactly what I said. I basocally said that I do agree that people should have a slight understanding about history, artwork, and important events but I for one, will admit that I have a trouble trying to adjust to learning it. If I am not interested in something, you won't see me near it. I am specifically interested with children, so I either want to pursue elementary education of sport training. Why would I stress myself out and learn about something completely out of my path of pursued knowledge when I already have a but load of information that I MUST learn about my major. These are the questions I want to ask Bauerlein. He makes valid points about his excerpt but he refrains but common sense. Meaning that he bashes on our generation but we have the common sense to learn what he thinks we should learn but in different and new, innovative ways and that's ezactly what he fails to mention.

    ReplyDelete